Then Heather goes "what? is he checking to see if it's still there?!?!"

Hee! IIRC, Harrison said almost those exact same words!
As for the cute guys... good picks, all around!

To add some off the top of *my* head...
Probably surprising no one, I think the Hamm brothers are pretty good-looking. Red hair and freckles always turn my head. But...
I think Phelps' voice is OK... he sounded to me like your typical energetic, overeager 19-year-old. The Hamm brothers have what Harrison dubbed "Valley Boy" voices, though.
Let's see... there's also Blaine Wilson, and you can't go wrong with "Sexy Aleksi" Nemov.

Dimosthenis Tampakos was handsome, even if I still think that Jordan Jovtchev had a better rings routine.

On the diving side, I kind of have a bit of a soft spot for Dmitry Sautin, although he'd look better with hair.
Swimmers... Gary Hall would be good-looking, but he's too flashy for my tastes.
Hmm. For the women...
Gymnastics: Svetlana Khorkina would be pretty if she didn't spend most of her time with a look on her face like she's going to suddenly snap and scream and kill somebody.
I like Harrison's new favorite, Anna Pavlova.

Beach Volleyball: Kerri Walsh and Misty May!

Diving: I think Guo Jingjing was pretty.
Swimming: Amanda Beard. Mrrrow.
Peace & Luv, Liz