Scalpel is one of the best adventure games out there. Rose Tatooo is boring. Or maybe, because it came out in 97, it suffered from the same post-phantasmagoria games. Lack of cinematics. I think I finished it, but it bored me to tears.
Now Scalpel, I remember enjoying every little bit of this game. Such a great story.
And The Dig is among LucasArt's best game. I think it's very underrated. It's one of their only serious tone games, and it was just incredible. I replayed it recently before I went to work on Telltale (well, that's like 3 years ago now lol)