I didn't care for Secret of the Scarlet Hand nor Curse of Blackmoor Manor, so I wouldn't recommend starting with either of those. I love Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake, Message in a Haunted Mansion, and The Secret of Shadow Ranch. Of course, you can start with any of the games, but don't start with SSH or CUR...SSH was Aztec-like and if you can remember the names and stuff of the different Indians, then you're fine. CUR had quite a bit of voodoo type themes, and I just don't care for that at all.