Does anyone have the full-size version

[kindofdoon]

What Rosella said. He has said some needlessly rude, hurtful things to very nice people without reason. If he is a nice person, he has certainly not shown that in any of his actions.

[TheReturnofDMD]

He's not attacking anyone though. Judging by his actions, it is logical to assume that this person feels very disrespectful toward TSL and its team and is going out of his or her way to BE disrespectful and rude in a public setting. Those aren't the traits I look for in people, and I'm assuming that's what Doon meant.

Making judgments on someone based on what they say and do is legitimate.

He's (the VGA TSL person) making his own judgments it would seem.

[Fierce Deity]

He's not attacking anyone though. Judging by his actions, it is logical to assume that this person feels very disrespectful toward TSL and its team and is going out of his or her way to BE disrespectful and rude in a public setting. Those aren't the traits I look for in people, and I'm assuming that's what Doon meant.

Making judgments on someone based on what they say and do is legitimate.

He's (the VGA TSL person) making his own judgments it would seem.

But his judgments were uncalled for. The VGA TSL guy is clearly instigating. So if Doon (who may feel obligated to protect Phoenix from the slander that this guy is providing) responds with a judgment that is actually justified and reasonable, then he isn't as disrespectful as the VGA TSL guy. It's a simple Eye for an Eye situation. The original fault is uncalled for, but the latter is justified.   

[darthkiwi]

But his judgments were uncalled for. The VGA TSL guy is clearly instigating. So if Doon (who may feel obligated to protect Phoenix from the slander that this guy is providing) responds with a judgment that is actually justified and reasonable, then he isn't as disrespectful as the VGA TSL guy. It's a simple Eye for an Eye situation. The original fault is uncalled for, but the latter is justified.

I agree. If the VGA remake guy decided to publically mock PoS then I don't see why he should expect any sympathy on these forums.

[B'rrr]

Considering he intros his project by saying,

Just a few days ago the girls and gays at Phoenix Online Studios released their long-awaited adventure game The Sims Quest IX: Barbie Goes to Wonderland King's Quest IX: The Silver Lining...

I'm pretty sure he's not intending to flatter us.

It might not be his intention, but he is still doing so. Sure his tone is rude towards both the team and the game, but if he is really making a VGA version of TSL, it is flattery indeed.

[KatieHal]

hehe, there is that quote about imitation being the sincerest form of flattery I suppose

I don't want this thread to turn into a hate-fest, on that person or on anyone else, though. So let's make sure that doesn't happen, okay?

[Fierce Deity]

hehe, there is that quote about imitation being the sincerest form of flattery I suppose

I was thinking about the same quote, but I think that imitation doesn't include mockery. If he were to sincerely make a VGA version of TSL that was a serious project, and not a joke, I would consider that quote to be relative.

I don't want this thread to turn into a hate-fest, on that person or on anyone else, though. So let's make sure that doesn't happen, okay?

Aye, aye. No more hate-filled rants by me, from here on out. 

[darthkiwi]

I don't want this thread to turn into a hate-fest, on that person or on anyone else, though. So let's make sure that doesn't happen, okay?

Mmkay