I'm in the same boat as you, Katie!
My last spoilers were from the game
Arx Fatalis which is a game with remarkable world-building and a decent story, just... y'know, not great writing (every single "plot twist" is predictable, there's various places where they *give* you exposition instead of letting you uncover it, etc), the worst voice acting in any video game
ever (but you can't play it on mute, there's a lot of stuff you need to know that isn't subtitled!

), and the gameplay is...uh... well it has its strong points and its low points.
Anyways! From a totally different story....