I made all conversation in the church, too. I think I'm experiencing some kind of game bug, because I'm pretty sure I've done possibly anything possible (bear in mind I know original Gabriel Knight thoroughly, as I played it at least 5 times during last 20 years). That's why I posted in "Tech support" forum in the first place. But I know that remake version is slightly different, so maybe I forgot something? I checked the hint system, just to find out that I've done everything from the checklist for this day. My current score is now 117 by the way.
Any suggestions (I attach my save game)?